POETRY July 1, 2026

The Night We Quit Believing

2025 Susan Neville Prize Shortlist

Loud enough that the stained-glass Mary overhead overheard,

Stephanie says, I don’t believe anymore. Me neither, I say,

because she drives an eighty-eight red Camaro & I don’t

want to be left at church alone. We ditch & slink

into a corner booth at Dairy Queen, split a sundae,

scribble on fudge-stained napkins. She writes priests & I

suggest ties & slacks. She puts hell & ink & whipped

cream begin to bleed together, each ex-communication

another smudge on this soon-to-be crumpled church

that I’ll smuggle home in my pocket like a fist-

ful of sand. Banished: the Pope, all dress clothes, & any

homophobes; the Bible, George W. Bush, & “Teen Life”

nights; Jesus bumper stickers, Jesus crucifixion jewelry,

& the Jesus cracker. Canonized: our old friend Juan,

who would convince a new girl to hold his hand Fridays

after school as his drill sergeant dad pulled up to the curb

& honked. Stephanie’s hand in mine, I say, It looks like we

are praying. I don’t know it yet, but she will soon

be taken off life support. I don’t hear it, yet the sound

of two hands making one is the mouth setting a bed

for the soul, or something warmer, more corporeal

like a laugh in a well. Stephanie rolls her eyes, looks at me

like she did when I asked between bites of that sundae,

What do we believe? Her face says everything, says, Nothing

beyond this booth, says this is final, no takebacks, rip up

the scripture; our faith a phantasm, our god a dead letter.

Alex is at work on We Quit Believing, a book of poems about siblinghood, punk rock, God, and grief, to be released sometime in his lifetime. His poems, stories, and essays can be found in Epiphany, The Florida Review, Stoneboat, and others. He founded The Grief Commune, a magazine about the politics of collective grief, and he can be found on various social media hellscapes @alexisapoet.
Social Media: @alexisapoet